What Is Defamation Insurance and Which Policy Covers It?

Kevin Morrissy
6 min read
defamation insurance

Defamation insurance is rarely sold as a standalone policy. For most businesses, libel and slander claims are covered under the personal and advertising injury section of a general liability policy, while businesses that publish, broadcast or create content for a living buy media liability insurance, which covers defamation alongside copyright and privacy claims. If you are asking which policy protects you after an employee’s social media post or a reply to a bad review goes wrong, the answer is usually one you already have, with the exceptions explained below.

What is defamation, and how do libel and slander differ?

Defamation is a false statement of fact, communicated to someone else, that harms a person’s or business’s reputation. Libel is written or published defamation, which now includes websites, social media, emails and reviews; slander is spoken. Disparagement, a related claim, involves false statements about a competitor’s products or services, and most liability policies treat it alongside defamation. Insurance defends you when someone claims you defamed them, not when you are the one defamed.

Does general liability insurance cover defamation?

For most businesses, yes. Coverage B of a standard general liability policy, called personal and advertising injury, covers oral or written publication of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or disparages their goods, products or services, and pays defense costs plus any settlement or judgment up to the limit. A restaurant whose reply to a review calls the reviewer a liar would look first to this coverage.

The grant comes with exclusions that matter:

  • Knowing falsity. Statements made knowing they were false, or at the insured’s direction with that knowledge.
  • Media and internet businesses. No coverage for insureds whose business is advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting, or designing or determining the content of websites for others.
  • Electronic chatrooms and bulletin boards the insured hosts or controls, which can sweep in comment sections and community forums.
  • Prior publication. Material first published before the policy period.
  • Infringement of copyright, patent, trademark or trade secret, except in your own advertisement.

When do you need media liability insurance instead?

If content is your product, general liability will not respond. Publishers, broadcasters, podcasters, newsletter writers, influencers, advertising and PR agencies, web designers and anyone paid to create or distribute content for others fall under the media business exclusion. Media liability insurance is the professional liability form for those businesses: it covers defamation, disparagement, invasion of privacy, copyright and trademark infringement, plagiarism and negligent publication. Our media and web design insurance page describes the full program for agencies and creative firms.

Do cyber, E&O or D&O policies cover defamation?

Sometimes. Many cyber liability policies include a website media liability section covering defamation in content on your own site and social accounts, which fills the online-forum gap in general liability. Errors and omissions policies for marketing consultants often include personal injury coverage for client content, and some directors and officers policies include libel and slander by officers in their management role. None of these replaces general liability or media liability.

What does defamation coverage cost?

Because defamation coverage is part of a larger policy, there is no separate premium for most businesses. General liability for a small business typically runs $400 to $900 a year and includes personal and advertising injury, or it is bundled into a business owner’s policy. Media liability is priced on revenue, audience size and the kind of content produced.

How can a business reduce defamation risk?

Every employee with a phone is now a publisher, and the most common small-business claims involve replies to online reviews, posts about former employees or competitors, and comparative advertising. Defense costs on even a weak claim can reach five figures.

  • Write a social media policy covering company and personal accounts, and name who may speak for the business.
  • Route review responses through one trained person; respond to the experience, never to the reviewer’s character.
  • Have comparative advertising reviewed and keep the evidence for every factual claim about a competitor.
  • Correct promptly. A fast, visible retraction limits damages and is a condition of coverage in some media forms.

What should you do when a defamation complaint arrives?

Notify your insurer at once, before responding to the complainant. Preserve the post, email or recording; deleting it may breach the policy’s cooperation condition. Let the insurer’s appointed counsel evaluate truth, opinion and privilege defenses and decide whether to retract.

Get coverage that responds to a libel or slander claim

We confirm whether your general liability or BOP includes personal and advertising injury without a media exclusion that bites, and we quote media liability for agencies, publishers and creators who need it. Start with our general liability insurance page or request a quote. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.

Frequently asked questions

Can I buy a standalone defamation insurance policy?

Rarely, and for most businesses there is no need. Defamation, libel and slander are covered under the personal and advertising injury section of a standard general liability policy or business owner’s policy. Publishers, agencies and creators are excluded from that coverage and buy media liability insurance, which treats defamation as one of several covered content claims. Ask your agent to confirm which policy you are relying on.

Does general liability cover an employee’s social media post?

Often, if the post was made in the course of the business and the business is sued for it. Personal and advertising injury coverage applies to oral or written publication that libels or slanders someone, including online posts, but excludes statements made knowing they were false and forums the business hosts. A post on an employee’s personal account that identifies the employer can still produce a claim, so a social media policy matters.

Does defamation coverage apply to statements about a competitor?

Yes, within limits. The personal and advertising injury grant covers disparagement of another organization’s goods, products or services as well as libel and slander, so a competitor’s claim over a false comparison can be defended under general liability. The knowing-falsity exclusion applies, and the policy will not cover false advertising about your own products or trademark infringement. Keep evidence supporting every factual claim you make about a rival.

Does cyber insurance cover defamation?

Many cyber liability policies include a website media liability section covering defamation, disparagement, copyright and trademark infringement and privacy violations in content on your own website, blog and social media accounts, which is useful because general liability excludes forums you host. The coverage is usually limited to your own online content, so an agency or publisher creating content for others still needs a media liability policy.

Is stating an opinion defamation?

Generally no. Defamation requires a false statement of fact, and a pure opinion that cannot be proven true or false is not actionable. The line is thinner than it looks: an opinion that implies undisclosed facts, such as calling a former employee a thief, can be treated as a factual assertion. Truth is a complete defense. Insurance defends you either way, which is why the policy matters even when you believe you were right.