BOP vs. Commercial Package Policy: Which One Fits Your Business?

Kevin Morrissy
7 min read
Small-business owner seen from behind comparing two policy folders, a floor plan, and an inventory sheet at a worktable, with a shop floor ahead.

A business owner’s policy (BOP) is a pre-built bundle of property, liability and business income coverage for small, low-hazard businesses; a commercial package policy (CPP) is assembled part by part for businesses that are larger, higher-hazard, or need limits and forms the BOP does not offer. Buy the BOP if you fit its eligibility box, because it is cheaper and broader for the price. Move to a package when you outgrow the box or need a coverage part the form cannot carry.

What is a business owner’s policy?

A BOP is a single policy on a standard form that bundles commercial property (building and business personal property), general liability, and business income with extra expense for an eligible small business. The insurer prices the account from a short application and attaches endorsements from a fixed menu. Our BOP insurance guide covers what the bundle contains, who qualifies and the gaps; our business owner’s policy page covers how we quote one.

The trade: broad coverage at a bundled price in exchange for accepting the form as written and staying inside its eligibility range.

What is a commercial package policy?

A package policy is two or more coverage parts issued under one policy number: commercial property, general liability, inland marine, crime, and sometimes commercial auto or equipment breakdown, each on its own form with its own limits, deductibles and endorsements. The underwriter builds the policy to the business instead of fitting the business to a form, which is how a package carries a manufacturer, a contractor with a large tool schedule, or a restaurant with a bar. The price of that flexibility is more underwriting and more decisions.

Who fits a BOP and who fits a package policy?

A BOP fits a business inside the typical underwriting ranges: under about 100 employees, under about $5 million in revenue, buildings under roughly 35,000 square feet, and a low-hazard class such as offices, retail, small restaurants, service businesses and small contractors. Ranges vary by insurer, and each publishes its own eligible-class list.

A package policy fits a business that fails one of those tests or needs a part no BOP program offers:

  • Larger than the BOP ranges in revenue, headcount or building size.
  • A higher-hazard class: manufacturing, trucking, heavy contractors, bars, auto service, anything with pollution exposure.
  • Several locations with different exposures, or buildings of unusual construction or occupancy.
  • Property the BOP will not write: a large inland marine equipment schedule, high-value stock, or business income that needs a stated limit.
  • Contract or lender requirements for forms, limits or endorsements the BOP cannot carry.

If you are inside the ranges and a BOP is available, take it; a package bought by a BOP-eligible business usually costs more for parts it does not need.

How do the two compare on coverage?

Property

Both insure the building and business personal property for direct physical loss on an open-perils basis, with the same core exclusions: flood, earthquake, wear, and equipment breakdown unless endorsed. The BOP form pays replacement cost with no coinsurance clause. The standard commercial property form on a package applies coinsurance of 80%, 90% or 100%, so a building insured below the required share of its value takes a penalty on every partial loss. Deductibles for small businesses commonly run $500 to $5,000 on either. Our guide to business property insurance covers valuation, coinsurance and setting limits.

Liability

General liability is close to identical on both. A package gives more room to raise limits, add endorsements for contract requirements, and attach a commercial umbrella above it.

Business income

On the standard BOP form, business income pays actual loss sustained for up to 12 months after a 72-hour waiting period, with 30 days of extended business income after you reopen, and no separate limit to size. On a package, business income is its own coverage part with a limit you choose, coinsurance options, and add-ons such as extra expense only, longer extended periods and dependent property coverage. Neither includes workers’ compensation, and neither includes professional liability except for a few classes on a BOP.

What is the cost difference?

A BOP for a typical small business runs roughly $500 to $3,500 a year. A package for the same business, if an insurer would write one, usually costs more: each part is rated separately with its own minimum premium, and the underwriter spends more time on the account. For a business that fits both, the BOP is almost always the lower premium.

What do you gain and lose when you switch?

Moving from a BOP to a package:

  • You gain higher and customized limits, additional coverage parts, scheduled property, and business income sized to your operation.
  • You lose the no-coinsurance property coverage, the automatic actual-loss-sustained business income, the bundled price, and the simplicity of one form.
  • You take on setting a business income limit and defending your property values against coinsurance, which means a current replacement cost estimate and a realistic contents inventory.

Moving back to a BOP reverses the list; check the BOP’s built-in sublimits against anything scheduled on the package.

How do you decide?

Answer four questions in order:

  • Are you inside the BOP ranges for size and class with at least one insurer? If not, the package is the answer.
  • Does any lease, loan or client contract require a limit, form or endorsement the BOP cannot provide? If so, a package, or a BOP plus an umbrella.
  • Do you have exposures the BOP’s sublimits cannot hold: a large equipment schedule, high stock values, income that would take more than 12 months to restore?
  • Will you cross a size threshold in the next year or two?

If every answer points to the BOP, buy it and spend the savings on the policies neither form includes; our small business insurance guide covers that order.

Get a quote for a BOP or a package policy

We check your class and size against several insurers’ BOP guides first, and quote a package only when the BOP will not write the business or carry what you need. Request a quote with your business description, locations, property values, revenue and payroll. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a BOP and a commercial package policy?

A BOP is one standard form bundling commercial property, general liability and business income for eligible small businesses, with endorsements from a fixed menu. A commercial package policy is two or more separate coverage parts (property, liability, inland marine, crime, sometimes auto) under one policy number, each with its own form and limits. The BOP is simpler and cheaper; the package fits businesses the BOP form cannot carry.

Is a commercial package policy more expensive than a BOP?

For the same business, usually yes. A BOP for a typical small business runs roughly $500 to $3,500 a year; a package on the same account rates each part separately with its own minimum premium and takes more underwriting. Across the market a package often costs more simply because the businesses that buy one are larger or higher-hazard.

Can a small business buy a commercial package policy instead of a BOP?

Yes, and some should: a small manufacturer, a contractor with a large equipment schedule, a restaurant with a bar, or any business a lender or client requires to carry forms or limits the BOP program does not offer. A business inside the BOP ranges with no such need usually pays more and gives up the no-coinsurance property coverage and automatic business income of the BOP form.

Does a BOP or a commercial package policy include workers’ compensation and commercial auto?

Neither includes workers’ compensation, which is always a separate policy. Commercial auto can be a coverage part on a package but not on a BOP, which can only add hired and non-owned auto liability for employees’ personal cars and rentals. Professional liability is outside both, except for a few classes that can add a limited version to a BOP.

When should I switch from a BOP to a package policy?

When you cross an insurer’s BOP range for revenue, employees or building size; when your class changes to something higher-hazard such as manufacturing, a fleet or a bar; when you need a part the BOP cannot carry, such as a large inland marine schedule or a stated business income limit; or when a lease, loan or contract requires limits or forms the BOP program does not offer.