By Dream Assurance Group · Reviewed by Kevin Morrissy
Business property insurance, also called commercial property insurance, pays to repair or replace your building, your business personal property and your tenant improvements after fire, wind, hail, theft, vandalism, a burst pipe or another covered cause of loss. What you collect depends on four choices made when the policy is written: replacement cost or actual cash value, special form or named perils, the coinsurance percentage, and the deductible. It excludes flood, earthquake, wear and tear and equipment breakdown, each insured separately. This guide explains each choice and how to set limits that pay in full.
What property does business property insurance cover?
A commercial property policy, whether it stands alone or sits inside a business owner’s policy, divides your property into three groups, each with its own limit. Get the groups wrong and a claim comes up short.
Building
The structure you own and everything permanently attached to it: roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, built-in fixtures, permanently installed machinery, and scheduled outdoor fixtures such as signs and fences. If you lease the space, you do not buy building coverage; your landlord does.
Business personal property
Everything you own inside the building that is not part of it: furniture, shelving, computers, equipment, inventory, raw materials and supplies, plus property of others in your care, such as customer goods left for repair. This is the coverage every tenant needs and the one most owners under-insure, because inventory and equipment grow faster than anyone updates the policy.
Tenant improvements and betterments
Walls, flooring, lighting, counters or a commercial kitchen that you paid for in a leased space and cannot take with you. The landlord’s policy values the building as it was before you improved it, so your business personal property limit should include the cost to redo those improvements. Most forms count them there automatically.
Should you choose replacement cost or actual cash value?
Replacement cost, almost always. The valuation clause decides how the insurer measures a loss:
- Replacement cost pays what it costs today to repair or replace with new property of like kind and quality, with no deduction for age or wear. A ten-year-old walk-in cooler is replaced with a new one.
- Actual cash value pays replacement cost minus depreciation.
Actual cash value lowers the premium but moves the gap onto you at the worst moment. It suits only property you would not replace, such as a building you plan to tear down.
What is coinsurance and how does the penalty work?
Coinsurance is the requirement that you insure property to a stated percentage of its full value, usually 80%, 90% or 100% on the standard commercial property form. Carry less and every claim, not just a total loss, is reduced in proportion to the shortfall.
The arithmetic: divide the limit you carry by the limit you should carry and multiply the loss by that fraction. A building worth $1,000,000 with 80% coinsurance needs an $800,000 limit. Insured for $600,000, a $100,000 fire loss pays 75%, or $75,000, less the deductible. You absorb the other $25,000.
Two ways to avoid the penalty:
- Keep limits current. Update building values every renewal from a replacement cost estimate, not market value or the tax appraisal, and update business personal property from an equipment list and your peak inventory.
- Ask for agreed value. The insurer accepts a statement of values and suspends the coinsurance clause for the policy year.
The standard BOP form has no coinsurance clause, one of its quiet advantages for a small business. It still never pays more than the limit, so accurate values matter just as much.
Special form or named perils: what is the difference?
The causes of loss form sets which events the policy pays for:
- Special form, also called open perils or all risk, covers any direct physical loss unless the policy excludes it. The burden is on the insurer to point to an exclusion. It is the form most businesses should carry and the form the standard BOP uses.
- Named perils covers only the causes listed: fire, lightning, explosion, windstorm, hail, smoke, aircraft, vehicles, riot, vandalism, sprinkler leakage and a few others. Theft, water damage from a burst pipe, falling objects and the weight of ice and snow are the common losses it leaves out.
How do deductibles work on a commercial property policy?
The deductible comes off each covered loss before the insurer pays, per occurrence rather than per item. Small businesses commonly carry $500 to $5,000. Watch for separate deductibles beside the main one: a wind and hail deductible, often a percentage of the building limit in hail-belt and coastal states, so 2% on a $1,000,000 building is $20,000 per storm; a higher theft deductible on retail and jewelry classes; and a separate equipment breakdown deductible when that endorsement is added.
What does business property insurance exclude?
The special form excludes a short list of causes, and each has its own fix:
- Flood and surface water, including storm surge and sewer backup. Insured by a separate flood policy or endorsement; our natural disaster insurance page explains the options.
- Earthquake and earth movement, added by endorsement with its own percentage deductible.
- Wear and tear, rust, corrosion, settling, rot and gradual seepage. Property insurance pays for sudden events, not maintenance.
- Mechanical and electrical breakdown, including power surge and short circuit inside your own equipment. Equipment breakdown insurance fills that gap, typically for a few hundred dollars a year.
- Pollution, mold, nuclear hazard, war and government action.
- Loss of income. The property form pays to rebuild. The profit you lose and the expenses that continue while you rebuild are paid by business interruption insurance, a separate coverage on the same policy.
Is your property covered away from the premises?
Only a little. The standard forms give a small extension, often $10,000 to $25,000, for business personal property temporarily off the premises or in transit. Tools on a truck, equipment that moves from job to job, goods in transit and anything that lives at customer locations need an inland marine policy, which follows property wherever it goes.
How do you set the right limits?
- Building: a replacement cost estimate from your insurer or a contractor, updated every year. Purchase price, market value and assessed value do not measure what it costs to rebuild. Add ordinance or law coverage if the building predates the current code, because the policy otherwise pays to rebuild to the old standard only.
- Business personal property: every category of equipment, furniture and inventory at today’s replacement price, using the peak month for inventory, plus the cost to redo tenant improvements.
- Electronic data, valuable papers, accounts receivable and outdoor signs: each has a small sublimit on the standard form. Raise the ones that matter.
If your building outgrows the size and value ranges the standard BOP form accepts, the same coverage moves to a commercial package policy with scheduled limits; our BOP vs. commercial package policy post explains the trade.
Get a business property insurance quote
We write commercial property for owners and tenants in 36 states, as a stand-alone policy or inside a BOP, and we build the limits from a replacement cost estimate and an equipment list before quoting. Request a quote with your address, year built, square footage, construction type and a rough value for contents and inventory. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between building coverage and business personal property coverage?
Building coverage insures the structure and everything permanently attached to it: roof, mechanical systems, built-in fixtures and installed machinery. Business personal property insures what you own inside that is not part of the building: furniture, equipment, computers, inventory and supplies, plus property of others in your care. Owner-occupants need both. Tenants need business personal property only, with a limit that includes their improvements.
Is replacement cost or actual cash value better for business property?
Replacement cost, for almost every business. It pays the cost to repair or replace with new property of like kind and quality, with no deduction for depreciation. Actual cash value pays replacement cost minus depreciation, so older equipment and buildings are reimbursed at a fraction of what replacing them costs. It lowers the premium and suits only property you would not replace.
What is a coinsurance penalty on commercial property insurance?
The coinsurance clause requires you to insure property to 80%, 90% or 100% of its value. If your limit is below that, every claim is reduced in proportion to the shortfall. A building worth $1,000,000 under an 80% clause needs an $800,000 limit; insured for $600,000, a $100,000 loss pays $75,000 less the deductible. Current limits or an agreed value endorsement avoid the penalty. The standard BOP form has no coinsurance clause.
Does business property insurance cover flood and earthquake?
No. The standard commercial property form and the standard BOP form both exclude flood, surface water, storm surge, sewer backup, earthquake and other earth movement. Flood is insured through a separate flood policy or endorsement; earthquake is added by endorsement with its own percentage deductible. Water from a burst pipe inside the building is covered on the special form; it is not flood.
Does commercial property insurance cover equipment that breaks down?
No. Property insurance pays for damage from outside causes such as fire, wind or theft. Mechanical and electrical breakdown inside your own equipment, including motor burnout, compressor failure, power surge and short circuit, is excluded on the standard form. Equipment breakdown coverage, added by endorsement to a BOP or property policy, fills that gap for a few hundred dollars a year and also pays for spoiled stock after a breakdown.