By Dream Assurance Group · Reviewed by Kevin Morrissy
Nonprofit directors and officers (D&O) insurance pays the legal defense costs, settlements and judgments when board members, officers or the organization itself are sued over how the nonprofit was managed. It covers allegations like mismanaged funds, failure to follow bylaws or regulations, and breach of fiduciary duty, and most nonprofit forms also fold in employment practices claims. Without it, a volunteer board member’s personal assets can be on the line for a decision made in good faith.
What does nonprofit D&O insurance cover?
A nonprofit D&O policy responds to a wrongful act, which the policy defines broadly as an actual or alleged error, omission, misstatement or breach of duty by a director, officer, trustee, committee member, employee or volunteer acting on the organization’s behalf. The claims we see most often fall into a few groups.
- Mismanagement of funds. A donor, member or regulator alleges that the board made poor investment decisions, misapplied restricted gifts or failed to oversee spending.
- Regulatory and compliance failures. The organization did not meet a state or federal requirement, and the board is blamed for the lapse.
- Breach of fiduciary duty. A director is accused of putting personal interests ahead of the organization’s, or of failing to exercise reasonable care in oversight.
- Failure to follow bylaws. Improper elections, meetings without quorum, or decisions outside the board’s authority.
- Employment practices claims. Wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment and retaliation. Many nonprofit D&O forms include this coverage; where they do not, it is bought separately as EPLI.
The policy pays attorney fees and court costs from the first day of the claim, even when the allegation turns out to be baseless. For most nonprofits the defense cost is the real exposure, because many claims never reach a judgment but still take months of legal work to resolve.
Who can sue a nonprofit board?
More people than most boards expect. Claims against nonprofit directors come from donors and grant makers, members and beneficiaries, employees and former employees, volunteers, vendors, other nonprofits, state attorneys general and federal agencies. The organization itself can also sue a director. Because so many parties have standing, D&O is not a coverage reserved for large charities with investment portfolios; a small community organization with three employees and a volunteer board carries the same categories of exposure.
How is nonprofit D&O structured?
Most nonprofit policies include three insuring agreements, usually called Side A, Side B and Side C.
- Side A pays an individual director or officer directly when the organization cannot or will not indemnify them, for example because it is insolvent or its bylaws prohibit it. Our Side A D&O explainer covers when stand-alone Side A limits make sense.
- Side B reimburses the organization when it does indemnify its directors and officers.
- Side C, or entity coverage, protects the nonprofit itself when it is named in the suit alongside its leadership.
Together they mean the board, the executive team and the organization are covered by one policy with one limit, so the limit you choose has to be large enough to defend several parties at once. Our general D&O insurance guide goes deeper on how the sides interact.
How does D&O help a nonprofit recruit board members?
Experienced professionals are increasingly reluctant to join a board that cannot show it carries D&O. State volunteer-protection laws help, but they have exceptions, and a prospective director has no way of knowing whether a future claim will fall inside one. A D&O policy answers the question before it is asked, and a certificate of coverage is a standard part of a board recruitment packet. The same applies to advisory committees and officers who are not directors; make sure the policy’s definition of insured persons includes them.
What does nonprofit D&O insurance cost?
The typical figure we see is a median of around $70 per month, though the premium can run higher or lower with the organization’s risk profile. The main rating factors are:
- What the nonprofit does. Counseling, youth programs and housing carry more exposure than a historical society or a garden club.
- Annual revenue and assets. Larger budgets mean larger potential claims.
- Number of employees. Employment practices claims are the most frequent D&O claim for nonprofits, so headcount matters.
- Location. State law and local litigation patterns affect the rate.
- Claims history and governance. Written conflict-of-interest, whistleblower and document-retention policies help the underwriting.
What does nonprofit D&O insurance not cover?
- Bodily injury and property damage. Those are general liability claims.
- Deliberate fraud and criminal acts, once established in court.
- Claims you knew about before the policy started, or that were reported under a prior policy.
- Failure to buy adequate insurance. The policy will not pay a claim that exists only because the organization underinsured another exposure.
- Insured vs. insured claims in some forms, where one covered person sues another, though most nonprofit policies carve back whistleblower and derivative suits.
- Employee benefit plan errors, which belong to a fiduciary liability policy.
- Professional services errors, such as a counseling or social services mistake, which need a separate professional liability policy.
What other coverage does a nonprofit need alongside D&O?
D&O protects the people who govern the organization. It does not protect the building, the vehicles, the volunteers at an event or the clients you serve. A typical nonprofit program adds:
- General liability, or a business owner’s policy that bundles general liability with property coverage.
- Professional liability if staff provide counseling, care, education or advice.
- Workers’ compensation, required in most states once you have employees.
- Employment practices liability, either inside the D&O form or stand-alone.
- Crime and employee dishonesty coverage, because volunteer-run finance functions are a common theft target.
- Hired and non-owned auto, for staff and volunteers driving on the organization’s behalf.
Our nonprofit insurance page lays out the full program, and our church insurance page covers the religious-organization version.
Protect your board before the next meeting
We quote nonprofit D&O as a stand-alone policy or as part of a complete nonprofit program, and we will review your bylaws’ indemnification language so the policy fills the gaps rather than duplicating them. Start with our directors and officers liability insurance page or request a quote. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.
Frequently asked questions
Do small nonprofits really need D&O insurance?
Yes. The most common nonprofit D&O claims are employment disputes and donor or member complaints about governance, and neither depends on the size of the budget. A small organization also has fewer reserves to pay for a legal defense out of pocket.
Does nonprofit D&O insurance cover volunteers?
Most nonprofit D&O forms define insured persons to include directors, officers, trustees, employees, committee members and volunteers acting on the organization’s behalf. Confirm the definition in your policy rather than assuming.
Is EPLI included in nonprofit D&O?
Often, but not always. Many nonprofit D&O policies include employment practices liability under the same limit, sometimes with a separate retention. If yours does not, buy EPLI separately, because employment claims are the most frequent claim against nonprofits.
Does D&O insurance protect a board member’s personal assets?
Yes. Side A coverage pays an individual director or officer directly when the nonprofit cannot indemnify them, which is the situation where personal assets would otherwise be exposed.
Are nonprofit directors protected by law without insurance?
Partly. Federal and state volunteer-protection statutes limit liability for uncompensated directors in some circumstances, but they have exceptions for gross negligence, willful misconduct and certain claim types, and they do not pay for the defense. D&O fills those gaps.