By Dream Assurance Group · Reviewed by Kevin Morrissy
Primary and noncontributory wording makes your general liability policy pay a covered claim first, in full, without asking the other party’s insurer to chip in. A waiver of subrogation stops your insurer, after it pays, from suing the other party to recover the money. The first clause is about who pays; the second is about who gets sued afterward. General contractors and landlords ask for both, each requires its own endorsement, and together they typically add $0 to $300 a year to a small business policy.
What does primary and noncontributory mean?
Every liability policy has an “other insurance” condition that says what happens when two policies cover the same loss; left alone, most share the claim proportionally. Primary and noncontributory wording overrides that for a specific party: your general liability insurance responds first (primary) and does not ask the other party’s insurer to contribute (noncontributory).
The clause only matters when the other party has coverage under your policy, which is why it is almost always paired with additional insured status. Picture a general contractor named as an additional insured on a subcontractor’s policy. A worker is injured by the subcontractor’s work and sues the general contractor. With primary and noncontributory wording, the subcontractor’s insurer defends and pays the claim up to its limits before the general contractor’s own policy is touched. Without it, the two insurers argue over shares and the general contractor’s loss history and premium take the hit. That is the point from the general contractor’s side: the risk of the work stays with the party doing the work.
What does a waiver of subrogation mean?
Subrogation is the insurer’s right, after paying a claim, to step into your shoes and sue whoever caused the loss. A waiver of subrogation gives up that right against a named party or, on a blanket form, against anyone your written contract requires you to waive it for.
Take a tenant whose employee is hurt because a landlord’s stairwell was poorly lit. The tenant’s workers’ compensation insurer pays the medical bills, then would normally sue the landlord to recover them. If the lease required the tenant to waive subrogation in the landlord’s favor, that lawsuit never happens. The landlord asked for the waiver precisely so that the tenant’s losses stay on the tenant’s policies, even when the landlord contributed to them.
A waiver does not change what your policy covers, does not add anyone as an insured and does not decide who pays first.
How are the two clauses different?
They answer different questions about the same claim:
- Primary and noncontributory answers “whose insurance pays first?” It governs the order between two policies that both cover the loss, and only works alongside additional insured status.
- Waiver of subrogation answers “can my insurer come after you later?” It governs recovery after a payment, stands alone, and is routinely required on workers’ compensation and auto policies where additional insured status does not apply.
Most construction and lease exhibits ask for both. Satisfying one does not satisfy the other, and a certificate showing the boxes checked proves neither unless the endorsements are actually on the policy.
Why do general contractors and landlords ask for both?
Because together they make the risk transfer complete. The upstream party’s goal is that any loss connected with your work is paid by your insurance and stays off its own loss record. Additional insured status gets your policy to respond to claims against them. Primary and noncontributory wording makes your policy respond first. The waiver of subrogation ensures that once your insurer has paid, it cannot recover from them even if they share the blame. Remove any one of the three and the transfer leaks.
For the party giving the wording, your policy absorbs losses your client partly caused, and your insurer cannot recover from them. That is normal in construction and commercial leasing, but it is not free, so it belongs in the price of the job.
How do these clauses work with additional insured status?
Additional insured status is the foundation; the two clauses adjust how it operates. Primary and noncontributory wording appears either inside the additional insured endorsement or as a separate endorsement that applies only to additional insureds you have agreed by contract to treat that way. Many blanket additional insured endorsements include it automatically, but older or narrower forms do not, so check the contract wording against the actual endorsement rather than the certificate. Our post on additional insured vs. certificate holder explains the status itself, and our guide to what a certificate of insurance is shows where the checkboxes for additional insured and subrogation waived sit on the form.
Which policies can carry these endorsements?
- General liability. Both clauses are routinely available, usually as blanket endorsements that apply to any party your written contract requires.
- Commercial auto. All three are available on most policies and are regularly required by general contractors and delivery clients.
- Workers’ compensation. Only the waiver of subrogation applies; there is no additional insured status on a workers’ compensation policy. Workers’ compensation waivers are priced differently, as covered below.
- Umbrella. A commercial umbrella generally follows the underlying policy’s provisions, but a contract that requires the umbrella itself to be primary and noncontributory needs a specific endorsement.
- Professional liability. Most insurers will not add either clause. Negotiate the requirement out rather than promise it.
What do primary and noncontributory and waiver endorsements cost?
On general liability, a blanket waiver of subrogation endorsement typically costs $0 to $150 a year, and primary and noncontributory wording is usually included with a blanket additional insured endorsement at $100 to $300 or added for $0 to $100 on its own. Scheduled versions naming one party are often free.
Workers’ compensation is the exception. A waiver there is charged as a percentage of the premium for the work covered by the waiver, typically 2% to 5%, with a small minimum per waiver. A contractor with $100,000 in annual workers’ compensation premium and waivers on every job pays several thousand dollars a year for them, which belongs in the bids.
What should you check before agreeing to the wording?
- Read the contract’s indemnity clause first. The insurance clauses back up a hold-harmless agreement; if the indemnity is broader than your policy covers, the endorsements will not close the gap. Our post on contractual liability insurance explains that exclusion and its insured contract exception.
- Confirm the endorsements are blanket or name the right party, using the exact legal name from the contract.
- Sign the contract before work starts. Most blanket forms apply only to a written contract signed before the loss.
- Ask which policies the wording applies to. Agree for general liability, auto and workers’ compensation; push back on professional liability.
- Price the workers’ compensation waiver into the job.
- Send the endorsements with the certificate. Checked boxes on the certificate are not proof; the endorsement pages are.
Our guide to contract insurance requirements covers the rest of the insurance exhibit, including limits and notice of cancellation.
Get a general liability quote
We write general liability, auto and workers’ compensation with blanket additional insured, primary and noncontributory and waiver of subrogation endorsements for contractors, tenants and vendors who sign these clauses every month, and we read the contract before the certificate goes out. Request a quote to start. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between primary and noncontributory and a waiver of subrogation?
Primary and noncontributory decides which policy pays first when two policies cover the same claim: yours pays first and does not ask the other party’s insurer to share. A waiver of subrogation applies after a payment and stops your insurer from suing the other party to recover what it paid. One governs the order of payment, the other governs recovery, and a contract that asks for both needs two separate endorsements.
Does a waiver of subrogation add the other party to my policy?
No. A waiver of subrogation only gives up your insurer’s right to recover from the waived party after a claim is paid. It does not make them an insured, does not give them a defense under your policy and does not change the order in which policies respond. If the contract wants the other party covered, it will ask separately for additional insured status, and if it wants your policy to pay first it will ask for primary and noncontributory wording.
How much does a waiver of subrogation cost?
On a general liability policy a blanket waiver of subrogation endorsement typically costs $0 to $150 a year, and single-party versions are often free. On workers’ compensation it is charged as a percentage of the premium for the work covered by the waiver, typically 2% to 5% with a small minimum per waiver, which adds up for contractors who provide one on every job. Price it into the bid.
Should I agree to primary and noncontributory wording?
Yes, when the party asking is a general contractor, project owner, landlord or client genuinely exposed to claims from your work, because it is standard in those contracts and the endorsement is inexpensive. Confirm your policy’s additional insured endorsement includes primary and noncontributory wording or add it, and make sure the contract is signed before work begins. Decline it for professional liability, where insurers rarely offer the wording.
Can a certificate of insurance prove these clauses are in place?
Not by itself. The standard certificate has checkboxes for additional insured and subrogation waived, and agents often type the wording into the description box, but the certificate expressly confers no rights and does not amend the policy. The proof is the endorsement itself. Send a copy of the additional insured, primary and noncontributory and waiver of subrogation endorsements with the certificate, and keep the signed contract that triggers the blanket forms.