Employee Dishonesty Insurance: What It Pays, How Claims Work and How Much to Buy

Employee Dishonesty Insurance

Employee dishonesty insurance, called employee theft coverage on the standard commercial crime form, pays your business back for money, securities and property stolen by your own employees. It is the core agreement of a crime policy and the only piece most small businesses get on a business owner’s policy, where the sublimit is commonly $10,000 to $50,000. This guide covers what it pays, how it compares with a fidelity bond and a full crime policy, the discovery period, and underwriting controls.

What does employee dishonesty insurance cover?

Direct loss of money, securities and other tangible property stolen by an employee, acting alone or with others, whether the property is yours or held for someone else. The schemes insurers pay for most: skimmed cash, checks written to the employee or a shell vendor, ghost employees and inflated payroll, invoices from a company the employee controls, electronic transfers to the employee’s own account, and inventory sold out the back door.

Owners, partners and members are never employees, so theft by a part-owner is excluded; leased workers, volunteers and plan trustees can be added by endorsement.

Not covered: lost income or interest, your investigation and legal costs, losses proved only by an inventory count, and theft by anyone whose prior dishonesty you knew about; coverage for that person ends the day you learn of it. The agreement also does not pay when an honest employee is deceived into sending money to an outsider. That is a social engineering loss, explained in our social engineering insurance guide, and it needs its own endorsement with a callback verification condition.

How is it different from a fidelity bond and a full crime policy?

  • Employee dishonesty coverage insures your business against theft by your employees, sold as the employee theft agreement on a crime policy, as a standalone policy, or as a BOP endorsement. Our employee dishonesty insurance page covers how we quote it.
  • A fidelity bond covers the same peril but is usually bought because someone else requires it: a business services bond protects your clients from theft by your employees, and a retirement plan bond protects plan assets. Our fidelity bond page covers the types.
  • A full crime policy adds forgery, money and securities inside and outside the premises, computer fraud, funds transfer fraud and counterfeit money, each with its own limit. Our crime insurance guide walks through each agreement.

How much coverage do you get on a BOP versus a crime policy?

The business owner’s policy offers employee dishonesty as an optional endorsement with a sublimit commonly $10,000 to $50,000, for a small added premium on a policy that itself runs roughly $500 to $3,500 a year. The same exclusions apply.

A standalone crime policy commonly carries $100,000 to $1 million for employee theft. The gap is the point. A BOP endorsement covers a cashier with a till; it does not cover a bookkeeper with online banking access, who can move more than the sublimit in an afternoon. Size the limit to the most one trusted person could take before your reconciliation would catch it; these schemes typically run for years.

How does the discovery period work on a claim?

  • On a loss sustained form, the theft must occur during the policy period and be discovered during it or within the extended discovery period after expiration, commonly 60 days to 1 year, with limited reach-back to prior policies.
  • On a discovery form, the theft is covered if you discover it during the policy period, whenever it happened.

Either way the clock starts at discovery: the moment you first learn facts that would lead a reasonable person to assume a covered loss occurred, even before you know the amount. From that date you have a short window to notify the insurer and a set period to file a sworn proof of loss. You will need bank records, the personnel file and evidence tying the loss to the person, which is why an inventory shortage alone is not enough.

What controls do underwriters ask about?

  • Segregation of duties. Does the person who reconciles the bank account also sign checks or enter invoices? A no here raises the premium or lowers the offered limit.
  • Bank reconciliation monthly, by someone who does not handle receipts or disbursements.
  • Dual authorization on checks and transfers above a threshold.
  • Vendor controls: written approval for new vendors and for changes to bank details.
  • Background checks on hires with access to money or accounting systems.
  • Audits and surprise counts of cash and inventory.

Every yes lowers the premium or raises the limit on offer.

What does an employee dishonesty claim look like?

An office manager at a small nonprofit handles deposits and pays bills with no second signature. Over several years she writes checks to herself coded as program expenses. A new treasurer finds it when the bank balance does not match the books. The agreement pays the direct loss up to the limit, less the deductible, once the organization documents who took what; the investigator, the lawyer and the lost income are not covered unless endorsed.

Get an employee dishonesty insurance quote

We quote employee theft coverage as a BOP endorsement, a standalone policy or part of a crime package. Request a quote with your employee count, who handles receipts and payments, and your reconciliation and approval controls. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.

Frequently asked questions

What does employee dishonesty insurance cover?

Direct loss of money, securities and other tangible property stolen by your employees: skimmed cash, checks written to themselves or a shell vendor, payroll schemes, fake invoices, electronic transfers to their own accounts and stolen inventory. It does not pay lost income, investigation costs or legal fees, losses proved only by inventory count, theft by owners, or theft by anyone whose prior dishonesty you knew about.

Is employee dishonesty insurance the same as a fidelity bond?

They cover the same peril, theft by employees, but serve different buyers. Employee dishonesty coverage protects your own business and is sold on a crime policy, as a standalone policy or as a BOP endorsement. A fidelity bond is usually bought because a client, a retirement plan or a licensing rule requires it, and a business services bond protects your clients rather than you.

How much employee dishonesty coverage is on a BOP?

The optional endorsement commonly carries a sublimit of $10,000 to $50,000 on a policy that itself runs roughly $500 to $3,500 a year. That is enough for a cashier with a till, not for a bookkeeper with online banking access, who can move more than the sublimit in an afternoon. Standalone crime policies commonly carry $100,000 to $1 million for employee theft.

What if the theft started before my policy began?

It depends on the form. A discovery form pays for loss you discover during the policy period regardless of when it occurred, provided you did not already know about it. A loss sustained form pays for loss that occurred during the policy period and is discovered during it or within the extended discovery period, commonly 60 days to 1 year after expiration.

Does employee dishonesty insurance cover an employee tricked into wiring money?

No. Employee theft coverage requires a dishonest employee. An honest controller who wires funds to a fraudster posing as a vendor or executive was deceived, and the transfer was authorized, so the voluntary parting exclusion also defeats the crime policy’s computer fraud and funds transfer fraud agreements. That loss needs a social engineering endorsement, with a sublimit and a callback verification condition.