By Dream Assurance Group · Reviewed by Kevin Morrissy
Contractual liability insurance is the coverage inside a general liability policy for liability you take on in a contract, most often through a hold-harmless or indemnity clause. The policy starts by excluding assumed liability, then restores it for an insured contract, a defined list that includes leases, easements, sidetrack agreements, municipal indemnities and any agreement in which you assume another party’s tort liability for bodily injury or property damage. That exception is what makes the indemnity paragraph in a lease, subcontract or vendor agreement insurable; it does not cover breach of contract, delays, defective work or promises to pay someone else’s losses that have nothing to do with injury or damage.
Why does general liability exclude contractual liability in the first place?
Every standard general liability insurance policy contains a contractual liability exclusion. It removes coverage for bodily injury or property damage you are obligated to pay only because you assumed that obligation in a contract or agreement. The reasoning is simple: the insurer priced your policy on your own negligence, not on every promise your sales team or a landlord’s lawyer might draft. Without the exclusion, a one-line clause could make your insurer responsible for a stranger’s conduct.
The exclusion then carves out two things. Liability you would have had anyway, with or without the contract, stays covered, because it is your own negligence. And liability assumed in an insured contract is given back, as long as the contract was signed before the injury or damage occurred. Everything written about contractual liability insurance is really about that second exception.
What counts as an insured contract?
The definition in a standard general liability policy lists five specific agreements plus one catch-all:
- A lease of premises, except the part that makes you responsible for fire damage to the space you rent, which is handled separately by the damage-to-rented-premises coverage.
- A sidetrack agreement with a railroad.
- An easement or license agreement, other than one for construction or demolition within 50 feet of a railroad.
- An obligation to indemnify a municipality that is required by ordinance, other than in connection with work for the municipality.
- An elevator maintenance agreement.
- The catch-all: any part of any other contract or agreement pertaining to your business under which you assume the tort liability of another party to pay for bodily injury or property damage to a third person or organization. Tort liability means liability that would be imposed by law in the absence of any contract.
The catch-all is where leases, subcontracts, vendor agreements, venue contracts and purchase orders fit. If a general contractor’s subcontract says you will indemnify and hold the general contractor harmless for bodily injury and property damage arising out of your work, and a visitor is hurt by your work, the general contractor’s liability that you agreed to absorb is covered under your policy as an insured contract. Defense costs you agree to pay for the indemnified party are also covered when the policy’s conditions for supplementary payments are met.
What does contractual liability coverage not cover?
The insured contract exception is narrower than most indemnity clauses, and the gap is where businesses get surprised.
- Breach of contract. Failing to finish on time, deliver what was promised or meet a specification is a business dispute, not bodily injury or property damage. No general liability policy covers it.
- Your own defective work. Repairing or replacing your work is excluded; only resulting damage to other property is covered, and that would be covered without any contract.
- Indemnity for the other party’s sole negligence. Many states refuse to enforce a clause that makes you pay for injuries caused entirely by the party you are indemnifying, and the policy covers only what the law would impose on the indemnitee anyway.
- Liability that is not tort liability. A promise to pay liquidated damages, fines, penalties or someone else’s lost profits is contractual, not tort, and falls outside the exception.
- Professional services. An indemnity clause in a design, consulting or IT agreement that covers errors in your advice belongs to an errors and omissions policy. Our E&O vs. general liability guide draws that line.
- Claims that are excluded elsewhere. The exception restores coverage only against the contractual exclusion. Pollution, employee injury, auto, aircraft and professional exclusions all still apply.
How do you read an indemnity clause?
Indemnity clauses come in three strengths, and the strength determines how much of the promise your policy will follow.
- Limited form. You indemnify the other party only for claims caused by your own negligence. Your policy would cover this without the clause. Always insurable.
- Intermediate form. You indemnify for claims caused in whole or in part by your negligence, which can leave you paying the other party’s share of a jointly caused injury. Covered as an insured contract, because you are assuming the other party’s tort liability for injury or damage, and this is the form most general contractors and landlords use.
- Broad form. You indemnify the other party for all claims arising out of the work or the premises, including those caused solely by the indemnitee. Many states void this form for construction contracts. Where it is enforceable, it technically fits the insured contract definition, but insurers rate it harder and some add an endorsement that limits the exception to the extent of your own fault.
Three other things to look for: whether the clause includes a duty to defend, which the policy covers only if the defense obligation is part of the same insured contract; whether it is capped at your insurance limits, which keeps the promise within what you have bought; and whether it is tied to an additional insured requirement, which gives the other party a second, more direct route to your policy. Our guide to contract insurance requirements for general liability covers the insurance exhibit that usually sits next to the indemnity clause and how to negotiate it.
Does contractual liability coverage cost extra?
For most small businesses, no. The insured contract exception is built into the standard form and the premium already reflects it. Where it costs money is at the edges: some insurers attach an endorsement that removes the catch-all and leaves only the five listed agreements, which is common for roofers, demolition contractors and other high-hazard classes. If your policy has that endorsement, a subcontract indemnity clause is not insured, and you need to buy the catch-all back or negotiate the clause down.
The other cost is indirect. A broad indemnity you give a general contractor means a larger share of a shared loss lands on your policy and erodes your aggregate, which is one reason trade contractors buy a commercial umbrella once their contracts stack up. A $1 million umbrella typically runs $500 to $1,500 a year.
What should you do when a contract asks for more than your policy covers?
- Strike or narrow the clause to the intermediate form, “to the extent caused by” your negligence. Most counterparties accept it because that is what their own insurer prefers.
- Add a cap tying the indemnity to the insurance you carry.
- Carve out professional services and point them to your errors and omissions policy if you give advice or design.
- Ask your agent for the actual policy wording. If the exception has been narrowed by endorsement, you need to know before you sign, not when the claim arrives.
- Keep a signed copy of every contract. The exception requires that the agreement be executed before the injury or damage; an unsigned subcontract is not an insured contract.
Contractors see this every week, and our contractor insurance program is built around reading the subcontract before the quote. For a wider view of what the policy does and does not cover, start with our hub on what general liability covers.
Get a general liability quote
Send us the indemnity paragraph with the quote request and we will tell you which part your policy follows and which part you are promising on your own. Request a quote to start. Dream Assurance Group is an independent agency in Overland Park, Kansas, licensed in 36 states. Email info@dreamassurancegroup.com with questions.
Frequently asked questions
What is an insured contract in a general liability policy?
An insured contract is the defined list of agreements for which a general liability policy restores coverage for liability you assume by contract. It includes leases of premises, sidetrack agreements, easements, municipal indemnities required by ordinance, elevator maintenance agreements and, most importantly, any part of a business contract in which you assume another party’s tort liability for bodily injury or property damage. Subcontracts, vendor agreements and venue contracts usually fall under that last category.
Does general liability cover a hold-harmless agreement?
Yes, to the extent the agreement makes you responsible for another party’s liability for bodily injury or property damage to a third person. That is the insured contract exception to the contractual liability exclusion. It does not cover promises to pay for breach of contract, delays, defective work, fines or lost profits, and the contract must be signed before the injury or damage happens for the coverage to apply.
Is contractual liability coverage automatically included?
In a standard general liability policy, yes. The exclusion and its insured contract exception are both built into the base form, so most small businesses pay nothing extra for it. Some insurers attach an endorsement for higher-hazard trades such as roofing or demolition that removes the catch-all definition and leaves only the five listed agreements. If your policy has that endorsement, indemnity clauses in subcontracts are not covered unless you buy it back.
Does contractual liability insurance cover breach of contract?
No. General liability responds to bodily injury and property damage, and the insured contract exception only restores coverage for another party’s tort liability for those two things. Missing a deadline, failing to deliver, poor workmanship that has to be redone and disputes over payment are business risks no liability policy insures. Errors in professional advice or design belong to an errors and omissions policy, not general liability.
What is the difference between limited, intermediate and broad form indemnity?
Limited form indemnity covers only claims caused by your own negligence, which your policy covers anyway. Intermediate form covers claims caused in whole or in part by you, including the other party’s share, and is the form most landlords and general contractors use; it is insurable as an insured contract. Broad form covers everything, including the other party’s sole negligence. Many states void broad form in construction contracts, and insurers rate it harder where it is enforceable.